A Review of Q3 2021

 

Q3 QUARTER’S RECAP

• U.S. economic growth slows in the face of Delta variant headwind
• Europe’s economic outlook remains positive
• Stocks retreat from record highs; confront a bevy of challenges

 

THE QUARTER IN BRIEF

Overcoming rising Delta variant infections, a slowing economic expansion, and growing inflation worries, stocks raced higher through the course of the first two months of the third quarter, propelled by strong corporate earnings, the absence of compelling investment alternatives to stocks, and a “buy on the dip” investor mentality. Investors, however, turned more cautious in September, wary of the season’s rocky reputation, persistently high levels of COVID-19 cases, the length of time that the market has gone without a meaningful retreat, and the fiscal and tax policies under discussion in Washington, D.C.

Amid this caution and absent any positive catalysts, September turned volatile, with stocks retracing their earlier gains as seasonal weakness was exacerbated by the mounting financial difficulties of a debt-laden, large property developer in China and rising bond yields.

Stocks steadied briefly following a Federal Reserve announcement that its bond buying would continue, with tapering of monthly purchases likely beginning in November and extending into mid-2022. However, a surge in bond yields in the closing week of the quarter unsettled investors and led to steep declines, especially in the technology and other high growth stocks. (Higher interest rates decrease the value of future cash flow, often resulting in lower current stock price valuations.)

In the end, September erased the gains built over the previous two months, leaving major indices largely flat for the third quarter.

Investors saw another quarter of exceptional corporate earnings growth. Second-quarter earnings exceeded Wall Street estimates for 87% of the companies comprising the S&P 500 index. Anticipating continued strength in earnings growth, market analysts have increased earnings estimates by 3.7%, expecting that the earnings growth rate will come in at 27.9% for the third quarter. If these estimates are realized, this would represent the third highest year-over-year earnings growth rate in over a decade.^1,2

 

THE U.S. ECONOMY

The momentum of the U.S. economic recovery slowed in the third quarter as a surge of Delta variant infections led to a deceleration in economic activity in industries such as travel, restaurants, and tourism. Economic expansion was further affected by supply bottlenecks and labor shortages. These supply bottlenecks were felt in multiple ways, from semiconductor chip shortages that limited auto production to delays of import deliveries from abroad due to factory and port closures in several Asian countries. Home sales were constrained by low inventory.

There were several economic sectors that continued their strong growth in the third quarter. These included manufacturing, transportation, non-financial services, and residential real estate.

Labor markets improved over the course of the last three months to the degree that employers were having difficulty finding workers. The Federal Reserve Bank ascribed a range of reasons for the worker shortage, including increased turnover, early retirements, childcare needs, challenges in negotiating job offers, and enhanced unemployment benefits.³

One consequence of this labor shortage has been an acceleration in wage gains, which may hold the potential for lower future corporate profits (if companies find that they are unable to pass on the higher cost) and higher inflation, as increased wages raise the costs of products and services.

Supply shortages, rising transportation costs, and wage increases have combined to create price pressures that have led to higher consumer costs in recent months. Reflecting these inflationary pressures were an 8.3% year-over-year jump in producer prices in August and a 5.3% 12-month increase in consumer prices.^4,5

The degree to which economic growth may have slowed in the third quarter won’t be known until October’s release of the Q3 Gross Domestic Product (GDP) report. However, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta, which tracks economic data in real-time, their model is indicating a 3.2% annualized real rate of GDP growth in the third quarter, a sharp retreat from its model’s prediction of 5.3% on September 1.⁶

The Federal Open Market Committee’s economic projections issued in September also reflect a more cautious view of the economy in the near term. GDP growth projections for 2021 were revised lower from June estimates, from 7.0% to 5.9%, while inflation estimates jumped from 3.4% to 4.2%.⁷

After plunging in August to near all-time lows, consumer sentiment steadied in September. Nonetheless, consumers are entering the final quarter of the year with a bleaker outlook due to heightened concerns over inflation.⁸

 

GLOBAL ECONOMIC HEALTH

The outlook for economic growth in European Union (EU) countries grew more positive with widening vaccinations, an improving health situation, and the easing of lockdown measures. The European Commission expects that output will return to pre-crisis levels by the fourth quarter of 2021. GDP growth estimates were lifted to 4.8% for 2021, while 2022 growth is expected to be 4.5%. Inflation estimates were raised to 2.2% for 2021 and 1.6% in 2022.⁹

The economic momentum that the United Kingdom enjoyed in the second quarter appears to be abating, owing to a resurgence in COVID-19 infections, staff shortages, kinks in the global supply chain, and continuing trade tensions with the EU. Nevertheless, the U.K. economy is projected to post a 6.6% growth rate for 2021 and a 5.5% expansion in 2022.¹⁰

After recording two successive quarters of strong economic growth, China’s economy is showing signs of slowing down. Flooding, higher input prices, and a surge in COVID-19 infections have all weighed heavily. A regulatory crackdown on a number of industries did nothing to improve conditions on the ground. It’s estimated that China will end the year with GDP growth rate of 8.5%, with a drop-off in 2022 to 5.5%.¹¹

Despite a pick-up in the pace of vaccinations, the Bank of Japan pared its economic growth estimate to 3.8% from 4.0% for its fiscal year ending in March 2022, though it raised its estimate for the following year to 2.7%, from 2.4%. Encouragingly, Japan announced in late September that it would be lifting the coronavirus state of emergency that was in place since April 2021. Finally, it’s unclear what the impact may be of the decision by Prime Minister Suga not to seek reelection, but it has created an overhang of political uncertainty.¹²

The MSCI-EAFE Index, which tracks developed overseas markets, slipped 1.03% in Q3, while emerging markets, as measured by the MSCI-EM (Emerging Markets) Index, plunged 8.84%.¹³

T I P   O F   T H E   Q U A R T E R

How financially literate are your children? Encourage them to read up on investing and money matters before they turn 18.

  

LOOKING BACK, LOOKING FORWARD

The third quarter was a reminder of how difficult it is to project the future amid a global pandemic. Investors entered July increasingly optimistic about an acceleration of the economic recovery, the prospect of rising vaccination rates, the reopening of schools, an easing in labor shortages, and a return to the office. By September, with the Delta variant lingering, employers delayed their plans for a return to the office, some mask mandates were reinstituted, and consumers pulled back on spending and travel.

Despite the deceleration in economic expansion, markets managed to climb to new record highs through most of the third quarter, though they stumbled in September.

If the market is to add to its year-to-date gains in the fourth quarter, it will need to climb a wall of worry. The worries include the expected start of tapering, global central bank tightening, fiscal and tax policy uncertainties, Covid infection levels, inflation, and whether corporate earnings can continue to impress in the wake of this quarter’s economic slowdown.

With the Federal Reserve’s September announcement that it may be set to begin tapering, the Fed joins a growing number of global central banks that have begun winding down the accommodative monetary policies that were put in place in response to the pandemic.

Of course, the pace of monetary tightening may be dictated, in part, by the prevalence of Delta variant infections over the course of the fourth quarter, as well as the state of labor market recovery, which continues to be prioritized over inflation by the Fed.

Inflation has touched levels not seen in over 40 years. Supply chain constraints continue to be a major factor in higher prices for businesses and, in turn, consumers. Especially troubling is that these bottlenecks may last for another year or longer. For now, the credit and equity markets seem to agree with Fed Chair Jerome Powell’s argument that inflation is transitory.

The question for investors is whether the markets will continue to accept that inflation is a transitory phenomenon should price pressures continue to rise through the fourth quarter.

While Washington may have been a tailwind for the market since hitting pandemic lows, it may turn out to be a headwind in the months ahead. Investors are wary of the impact on investments and corporate profits included in the proposed infrastructure plan and the new, higher taxes under discussion to pay for such spending.

Lastly, corporate profits and sales have exceeded market expectations in recent quarters, laying the foundation for the markets to move higher. As earnings are reported over the course of October and November, American businesses will need to once again show earnings growth that not only supports current price levels but also helps provide the rationale for higher valuations.

It’s a formidable wall to climb. Still, many of the conditions for continued stock market strength remain in place, specifically, a financially healthy consumer, an accommodative monetary policy (the Fed is not expected to hike rates until late 2022), strong corporate earnings, healthy economic expansion, and improving corporate cash balances.

 

MARKET INDEX	Y-T-D	Q3	Q2 to Q3 CHANGE
S&P 500	15.92	0.58	-7.97
Int’l Developed	8.35	-0.45	-5.62
Emerging Markets	-1.25	-8.09	-13.14
REITs	24.79	1.65	-11.20
Aggregate Bonds	-1.55	0.05	-1.78
YIELD	9/30 RATE	1 MO AGO	1 YR AGO
10 YR TREASURY	1.52	1.29	0.69

 

Sources: Wall Street Journal, September 30, 2021, Treasury.gov (Bond Yield)

Indices are unmanaged, do not incur fees or expenses, and cannot be invested into directly. These returns do not include dividends. 10-year Treasury real yield = projected return on investment, expressed as a percentage, on the U.S. government’s 10-year bond.

*International Developed is represented by the MSCI EAFE NR USD index. Emerging markets is represented by the MSCI EM NR USD index. REIT

is represented by the FTSE Nareit All Equity REITs TR USD index. Aggregate Bonds is represented by the BBgBarc US Agg Bond TR USD index.

 

Reach out to a Kaizen advisor if you wish to discuss this analysis or any other financial-related topics. We are happy to chat.  

 

CITATIONS:

1.  insight.factset.com, September 2, 2021

2. factset.com, September 10, 2021

3. federalreserve.gov, September 8, 2021

4. CNBC.com, September 10, 2021

5. WSJ.com, September 14, 2021

6. atlantafed.org, September 30, 2021

7. federalreserve.gov, September 22, 2021

8. sca.isr.umich.edu, September 30, 2021

9. ec.europa.eu, September 30, 2021

10. focus-economics.com, September 28, 2021

11. focus-economics.com, September 21, 2021

12. Reuters.com, July 16, 2021

13. msci.com, September 30, 2021